Trading Communities. Real Experiences.
Telegram has become an important part of the modern trading environment. Thousands of traders use Telegram groups to follow market analysis, trading signals and automated trading workflows.
At ForexBotWorks, we do not base our community reviews on advertising, promotional claims or screenshots published by the groups themselves.
Our reviews are based on personal experience — membership, observations, trading activity, recorded results and direct communication where applicable.
We share what we personally experienced so that you can make your own informed decision.
Our experience is not a guarantee of future performance.
Every community can change over time. Always verify current information before paying for any service or following any trading signals.
Fred Trading
A trading community we have personally followed since 2021, with XAUUSD as the primary market.
A Community We Have Followed Since 2021.
We have been members of Fred Trading since 2021. Our personal experience with the community has been primarily based around XAUUSD, which remains the main market we follow there.
Over the years, we have personally followed the community, its educational approach, trading activity and the way information is provided to members.
Learning Before Trading.
One of the things we personally noticed is the amount of educational material provided for beginners.
Instead of simply receiving signals, new members have access to a large collection of recorded videos explaining trading concepts and how the process works.
Members are expected to go through the training before becoming involved in the trading activity.
XAUUSD Is the Primary Focus.
Our experience with Fred Trading has been primarily focused on XAUUSD.
Trading takes place regularly and can be conducted on a daily basis. There are also periods when trading is paused depending on market conditions.
The community provides guidance around the trading process rather than simply leaving a beginner to interpret everything independently.
Invitation-Based Community.
The Telegram group cannot simply be joined through an open public invitation. Access requires an invitation code from an existing member.
Existing members can provide their personal invitation code to someone who wants to join the community.
Free Community
There is no paid membership required for the trading community itself.
Access is connected to registration with one of the supported brokers. Our experience has included Vantage and Starttrading.
Recently Added Options
More recently, funded-account options have also been introduced. The options we have seen include ERT Funded and Bullwaves.
This information reflects what we have personally observed as members.
35,458 Members
Community size observed on 18 September 2026.
Crypto Group
Fred Trading also has a separate crypto community. We are not members of that group, so it is not included in our personal assessment.
Based on Years of Personal Experience.
Our assessment is based on our own membership and experience since 2021. We have personally followed the community over several years and experienced its educational material, trading activity and member guidance.
What stands out from our experience is that the community does not focus only on providing trading signals. Considerable effort is also placed on educating beginners and explaining the trading process.
This is a personal assessment based on our experience as members. It is not a guarantee of future trading performance.
SureShot FX VIP Trading
Paid trading community offering access to multiple markets, VIP groups and a copy trading bot.
Paid Combo Package.
We personally joined the paid VIP service through the Combo Package.
The annual membership cost was $399 and provided access to the available Gold, Forex, Indices and Crypto groups, including VIP communities.
The package also included access to their copy trading bot.
Forex.
Although the Combo Package provided access to multiple markets, our personal focus was the Forex group.
The results and assessment documented on this page relate to our own Forex trading experience during the stated test period.
09 August — 22 August 2026
The Trading Results.
During the two-week test period, we recorded 48 closed Forex trades.
16 trades were profitable and 32 trades were losing trades, resulting in a recorded win rate of 33.33%.
Starting from $10,000, the account finished the test period at $3,603.67, with a realized loss of $6,396.33.
Delayed Response to Our Report.
We sent our two-week trading report to support on 22 August 2026.
We were told that the team would review the report. We did not receive a substantive response for approximately two weeks.
08–09 September 2026
After further contact, support acknowledged the losing trades and attributed the situation to unstable market conditions.
We were advised to use lower lot sizes and were told that the traders were attempting to recover the losses.
On 9 September, support stated that performance during the period had not been at its best and suggested that proper risk management may have contributed to the size of the loss.
Our Observation After Joining.
During our membership, we observed that the Forex and Gold VIP communities had approximately 50,000+ members.
This figure represents our observation during our membership period and is not presented as an independently verified company statistic.
We Do Not Provide a Link.
Based on our personal experience and assessment, we do not provide a link to this service from ForexBotWorks.
We Consider This Service a Scam.
Our assessment is based on our personal membership, the trading service we received, our recorded trading results and our direct communication with the support team.
We paid for the service, followed the Forex signals during the stated test period and recorded a realized loss of $6,396.33 from a starting capital of $10,000.
We also documented our concerns with the provider. Our two-week performance report was sent on 22 August 2026, followed by approximately two weeks without a substantive response. Further communication took place on 8 and 9 September.
This assessment reflects our personal experience and documented evidence. It is not a legal determination.
PrimeFX EA / Trading Service
Paid EA and trading service tested with a focus on trading performance, access requirements and provider transparency.
One-Month Test.
We purchased one month of the PrimeFX EA/service for $149 as a test.
Before purchasing, we expected to receive the EA and be able to run it ourselves.
Run the EA Ourselves.
Our expectation was straightforward: receive the EA, install it on MT5 and run it on our own trading environment.
Instead, the post-purchase process involved requests for access to our trading account and computer.
Account Credentials Requested.
After payment, support asked for our MT5 account number, MT5 password, server and lot size.
We refused to provide our trading password.
VPS and AnyDesk.
We were subsequently asked for VPS login credentials.
We do not use a VPS and explained that the EA would be running on our own computer.
We were then asked to provide AnyDesk remote access to the computer.
We refused all remote access.
EA Provided After Further Discussion.
Our question was simple: why should a customer need to provide an MT5 password, VPS credentials or AnyDesk access just to install and use an EA?
These requirements were not clearly disclosed to us before payment.
We therefore requested a refund.
After further discussion, PrimeFX eventually provided the EA file to us as an exception.
Our EA Test Results.
We also tested the PrimeFX EA itself after eventually receiving the EA file.
The EA was running on the M5 (5-minute) timeframe.
During our recorded test, we had 42 trades in total: 9 winning trades and 33 losing trades.
21.43% Win Rate.
That represents a recorded win rate of 21.43% and a losing-trade rate of 78.57%.
Based on our test results, the EA was not profitable for us during the period tested.
Winning Trades Were the Main Focus.
During our research, we observed that the official PrimeFX Telegram channel primarily presented winning trades.
We did not see the losing trades presented with the same level of visibility or consistency.
The Full Picture Matters.
Our concern is not that a trading system can have losing trades. Losses are a normal part of trading.
The concern is whether potential customers are given enough information to understand the complete trading performance, rather than mainly seeing successful trades.
Our own test of 42 trades resulted in 33 losses and 9 wins, which did not produce a profitable result for us.
Different Company Names.
During our research, we found several different company names associated with the service, including PrimeFx Ltd, Primefx Global Ltd, PRIMAL LTD and Prime FX LTD.
The payment transaction we received also showed Pay Zorg IT Group LLC.
ZORG IT Connection.
We found a documented public connection between PrimeFX and ZORG IT.
ZORG IT publicly presents PrimeFX as a client and states that it provided UI/UX, website development and branding services for primefxsignal.com.
Information We Found.
We also found that the Trustpilot profile for primefxsignal.com was claimed by PRIMAL LTD in July 2025.
The current PrimeFX website refers to PrimeFx Ltd and elsewhere states that the website is owned by Primefx Global Ltd.
Documentation, Not a Legal Accusation.
We are not making a legal accusation against any individual or company.
We are documenting what we personally experienced and what we found during our own research.
Serious Concerns About Transparency, Access Requirements and Trading Performance.
Our main concern is transparency. A customer should know which legal entity they are paying, what exactly they are purchasing, and what level of access the provider expects before making a payment.
Our own EA test also raised significant concerns. The M5 EA produced 42 recorded trades, with 33 losses and only 9 wins.
We personally would not provide our MT5 password, VPS credentials or AnyDesk access to a trading service.
Based on our experience, anyone considering PrimeFX should carefully verify the company identity, payment entity, access requirements, complete trading performance and independent trading evidence before paying.
This assessment reflects our personal experience and documented research. It is not a legal determination.